Executive Pastor Search

An executive pastor leads from the second chair as a trusted partner to the lead pastor, a strategic implementer, and a coach to the staff. We help you find the leader who fits your pastor, your team, and your culture.

Who It's For

• Lead pastors who need a trusted second-chair partner

• Growing and multisite churches that need operational leadership

• Elder boards restructuring the senior leadership team

• Churches replacing an executive pastor

​

What an Executive Pastor Does

• Strategic implementation: translate vision into action and drive execution across ministries and campuses

• Partnership with the lead pastor: serve as a trusted advisor and confidant

• Team leadership and coaching: coach campus pastors and ministry leaders

• Operational excellence: lead day-to-day operations and build systems for healthy growth

​

Questions to Answer Before You Search

• What does our lead pastor need most in a second-chair partner?

• Is our staff structure ready for this role, and who will report to it?

• Do we need a ministry, operations, or multisite leader, or all three?

• What chemistry and working style fit our lead pastor?

​

Our Search Process

Every search is customized to your church.

1. Partner with your team: a 360° view of your church, its structure, and its leadership team.

2. Clarify the second chair: align the lead pastor and board on scope, authority, and reporting, using our Organizational Structuring help when needed.

3. Build the role profile: responsibilities, qualifications, ministry experience, and character.

4. Recruit and screen: evaluate strategic, operational, and coaching ability, along with theological and cultural fit.

5. Compensation Analysis (included): market insight so your offer attracts and keeps the right leader.

6. Present a slate: qualified candidates who best fit the role and the culture of your church.

7. Chemistry and decision: interviews and visits focused on fit with the lead pastor and team, plus reference and background checks.

8. Onboarding support (included): an intentional onboarding plan so your new executive pastor is set up for success.

​

What You Get

• A 360° assessment of your church and staff structure

• A clear executive pastor role profile

• Guidance on reporting lines and organizational structure

• A slate of qualified, culture-fit candidates

• Compensation Analysis, included with every search

• Onboarding support for the first months, included

​

Frequently Asked Questions

What does an executive pastor do?

An executive pastor leads from the second chair as a trusted partner to the lead pastor, a strategic implementer, and a coach to the staff, overseeing how the church's vision is carried out.

What qualifications matter most in an executive pastor?

Significant church and ministry experience, a proven ability to implement strategic initiatives, strong leadership and coaching skills, excellent communication, and character that aligns with biblical principles.

Should we restructure before hiring an executive pastor?

It helps to clarify scope, authority, and reporting lines first. Our Organizational Structuring service can help clarify roles before the search begins.

​

Related Services

Executive Search (all roles), Church Succession Planning, Leadership Coaching, Strategic Growth Planning, Fractional/Interim Leadership

Start the Conversation

We'd be honored to walk alongside your team in this season.